Thursday, April 12, 2012
Christian Pressure
A few years ago I was watching a documentary on the Amazon and its Indigenous Peoples. Towards the end of the documentary they talked of missionaries coming to convert the natives and I was struck at what conversion did to the natives. Before, they were naked, happy, playful people who worked hard, played hard and generally enjoyed their place in life. After, they were clothed, unhappy, sour people who only worked hard and generally worried about their place in the after life.
It seemed to me that Christianity had become the apple.
The Amazon people before were much like Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden. But then Eve went against God and took a bite from the forbidden fruit. Doing so opened her up to sin and the realization of evil in the world. Not that I think the Amazon people were naive about evil in the world, and I'm sure their own religion had some aspect of sin and afterlife in it. What the indigenous people lacked was pressure.
I was in a religious chat room back when Yahoo used to have those kind of things (I miss them), and there was a rabidly religious person in there who talked about this dream he had. He was pressuring his sister-in-law to accept Jesus as her Savior and she resisted. She said she had no intention of believing (he made her out to be an Atheist) in the Christian God and would he just leave her alone about it. So he said he would until the dream. In the dream he saw his sister-in-law burning in hell and screaming, "Why didn't you try harder to save me?" Needless to say he was more gung ho about converting her, and everyone, than ever.
Pressure, pressure, pressure. We all know stress and frustration brings out the worst in people, so is it any wonder that folks under so much pressure to "save" everyone aren't people you like to be around so much? Once in a while you come across a happy person who basks in the glory of their God and what not. Yet I only count them as truly happy if they continue to be happy even after you say you don't believe. It never ceases to puzzle me how my not believing in their God will turn an otherwise happy person to concerned, then offended, and quickly to a mean spirited one. And that is before I go to the trouble of pointing out what the specific issues I have with Christianity are and why it is not the religion for me. It is hard not to offend them then, but I totally get it if part of your not believing goes with shooting holes in their faith.
Now part of me is like, well, if they truly believed (regardless of what their faith is), than my issues with their religion and how it doesn't work for me, should not rile them, but that is ignoring a lot of human nature there and doing them a disservice. So unless they trot out the bible quotes first, I don't start off with trying to pick a part their argument at all. I simply chose not to convert. I have faith and love for my own religion and Gods. All I ask is that they respect that. But, in large part, the religion itself does not allow them to do that. Pressure.
See, that is why if a retailer, smartly, markets to everyone, and not just Christians during the winter holidays, it is seen as a war on Christmas. Just the idea that there may be people who worship different Gods or none, and still have a celebration during the winter holidays is considered an affront. I get it, kinda. It is the pressure.
The pressure to convert everyone. The pressure to save everyone from hell. The overwhelming belief that Jesus died for EVERYONE, regardless of ethnicity, ancestry or belief, and it is up to every good Christian to make them believe it. Force them to "see the light."
Make. Force. Pressure. I don't know how many Christians can stand it.
Now I have met many wonderful Christians who subscribe to the point of view that conversion should be done by example and not talk. And I have met others who believe religion should be a mostly private, family, church oriented belief. I have met happy, open-minded Christians who don't prescribe to the pressure side of the religion. They are no accident. They had good, happy, open-minded Christian parents for the most part. Some choose to drop the shackles of pressure that comes with forcing conversion on those who don't want it. The hardest part with the later is to not drop out of the religion altogether because they failed the religion.
For many Christian sects, conversion is part of earning their way into heaven. THAT is a LOT of pressure! Belief is not enough. Good deeds aren't enough. Living a good life is not enough. Nope, they have to convert/save others. For every person they try to convert and don't, is a failure. So much pressure! So much happiness dependent upon the weak will of others. Yeah, it is one of the issues I have with Christianity.
The reason it is an issue for me is because Christianity is a religion not in any way endangered. In the popularity contest that is religion on this world, right now Christianity is first place. And maybe that is why all the pressure. They didn't work hard to get to where they are for no reason. I mean look at where they came from. I suppose it makes marketing sense to keep the pressure on. Snooze you lose. And they do have a couple of religions breathing down their necks, so to speak. Islam and Judaism aren't slackers. Buddhism may be laid back in comparison, but its no young pup to be ignored. Not that Christians ignore other religions. No. They don't ignore. They assimilate.
See I'm Native American so my religious beliefs are those of my ancestors. We don't convert. We do adopt on occasion, but we don't convert. It is not even in our lexicon. But Native American religions have been assimilated into Christian sects whether they wanted to be or not. Missionaries come in, find some similarities between the natives' beliefs and Christianity, no matter how obscure, claim Jesus already came to the new world and "saved" the natives, or natives are one of the lost tribes of Israel, and, bam, see, you've been Christians all this time and just didn't know it! It is wildly patronizing and condescending, but there it is.
With all the pressure to convert, is it any surprise Christians sometimes cheat? Like taking over Pagan rituals, ceremonies and celebrations as their own. Then denying the Pagan version ever existed. Kinda like when a big city annexes a smaller one. The smaller city goes on for a while as its own self, but, eventually, largely, it gets sucked into the larger city in thought as well as deed.
It is funny to me how some New Age Christians point at Catholicism and say it is not a Christian religion/church. Um, really? If you don't count the Coptics (which many don't), Catholicism is the oldest Christian organized church on the planet. The bible, sins, saints, missionaries, churches, Christmas, CONVERSION, etc. all exist because of Catholicism.
Let me point out something, however, that existed before Christians and churches: marriage. Yeah, not a Christian construct. The family, in all its different varieties, also existed before Christianity. And, believe it or not, morals did, too.
Part of me feels sorry for Christians who NEED to convert/save others. As explained above, that is a lot of pressure to live with. But, being the focus of most Christians attempts at conversion, I also hate them. Yes, I know it is a strong word, but I've been the subject of conversion for a very long time. I've suffered through the condescension, ridicule, judgement, and PRESSURE of being the target of good Christians. And, as explained above, I will always be a target because I have no intention of ever converting, and, in my and my children's lifetimes, there will always be a majority of good Christians who HAVE to convert/save others.
One great thing I never take for granted is that I and my family live in the United States. Probably the first country to ever make Freedom of Religion a part of its government. Or, er, religion as NOT a part of its government. :) I think about that first part of the first amendment every day. I do not take it for granted. The sudden insistence of incorporating Christianity into government lately scares the hell out of me. No lie. If that were to come to pass, what would happen to my family? Oh, the pressure!
Well, until that comes to pass, we chose to believe and worship as we wish. And our family, in the privacy of our home, will continue to be naked, happy, playful, joyful, content people for as long as we are allowed to be so.
May it always be so.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
"Yet I only count them as truly happy if they continue to be happy even after you say you don't believe." I loved that line.
ReplyDeleteIt's taken me a while to accept that there are "happy" Christians out there and then when I accepted it , so to speak, to trust them. I've had difficulty with this because I was the happy, "unhappy" type Christian before. I appeared happy and i convinced myself I was cause that's what I believed Jesus wanted from me but you're absolutely right, when it came down to others not being "saved" I was certainly not happy. How can anyone in their right mind be happy when their loved ones may possibly burn alive for ever. And when ya think about it, heaven is a promised place of no sorrow. But everyone in this supposed heaven has friends and family in hell. Do they just forget them? How can they not have sorrow with that hanging over their heads? It just doesn't add up.
My dream for myself was to be a missionary and convert people cause I didn't want anyone to go to hell and I thought Jesus was the only true road to happiness and I wanted others to be happy. It never occurred to me what a burden this was. Sure I would say it was actually Jesus responsibility, I was just a tool in the masters hand, but really... realizing everyone is gonna be screaming out in painful horror as their flesh is consumed by flames and they never die but are tormented for ever is just not a happy thought even if it all is up to Jesus. I'm just not heartless enough to actually be ok with it even when I tried to be.
So knowing how that feels to feel that way so strongly it is hard to disassociate other Christians from the way I was in my past. I'm getting there and will continue to get there all in good time. Being around "happy " Christians helps a lot and I'm blessed to be in the mist of some good ones.
I really enjoyed this blog. I feel you sister!
Unfortunately, protestant and RC missionaries tried to remake the culture into their own image. Orthodox Christian missionaries, on the other hand, present Christ as He is already revealed in the native culture (see the Orthodox missions to native Alaskans). God has given Himself a witness in every culture, a good missionary finds Him there.
ReplyDeleteThank you both. Having never been Christian myself, I can only comment on the pressure I see and feel, along with the desperation I get from my more Christian relatives (sorry, but feeling sorry for them is not enough of a reason to abandon my own Gods). Hearing it from two who have lived it, does flesh out my perspective quite a bit. The pressure is even worse than I thought! Understanding that pressure helps me not hate those who are only doing what they truly believe to be in my (and their) best interests. However, I wish I could show them how their views of my religion and Gods is so deriding and belittling. Sinking to their level and discounting their God in the same way does not work. And I truly don't want to go there. I really do strive to live by the Golden Rule. And, yes, I know it is considered a Christian concept, but the Rule is pretty much common sense and common decency to me. But how do you get them to realize what they are doing? I always struggle with whether it is even worth the effort to try and get them to SEE things from the perspective of those they are so fervently trying to convert.
ReplyDeleteSpeaking of deriding and ridiculing someone's religion, I hate it when it is done to anyone. When an Atheist gets all holier than thou about how Gods are just imaginary friends, it pisses me off! Or when someone of a modern religion tells an Indigenous person their Gods are myth. It is not cool to step on anyone's faith. Period. I stand up for myself and my faith, but I don't attack the faith of others. I can point out how much I don't like them personally, but I try very hard not to paint an entire group with one brush. I keep it down to a person by person basis. But then that is how all relationships and interaction should be. Be courteous and polite always. Give trust on an individual basis until an individual proves untrustworthy. Try not to hate. And never fear.
ReplyDelete